Water supply and sewerage – Mitigation
In addition to handling waste water in a manner that is safe for health and the environment, the purpose of water supply and sewerage is to secure one the basic needs of humans – supply of fresh water. On a national level, wastewater treatment produces small amounts of greenhouse gas emissions, while water supply and sewerage is also an indirect energy consumer, when a notable share of consumed heat energy is transferred outside residences along with wastewater.
Evaporative emissions from wastewater treatment dominate the greenhouse gas emissions of water supply and sewerage
Water supply and sewerage services produce drinking water for the needs of urban areas and handle the purification of their wastewater. Three quarters of the emissions of water supply and sewerage services originates in sewage disposal and the rest from the manufacture of drinking water.
Emissions from wastewater treatment are created when the nitrogen included in the wastewater is removed with the help of microbes. In addition to methane created in oxygen-free conditions, the handling processes release nitrogen compound breakdown products produced by microbes in the air. The evaporating methane and nitrous oxide form approximately 0.3% of the national greenhouse gas emissions. This amount corresponds to half of the greenhouse gas emissions for the entire water supply and sewerage.
Emissions related to the manufacture of drinking water are created by energy consumption
In addition to evaporative emissions, emissions are created in the production of energy needed by the treating processes. Direction and treatment of water require amply of electrical pumps and mixers. Drinking water manufacture emissions and approximately a third of the wastewater treatment emissions are caused by energy consumption. Compared to wastewater treatment, energy need per treated drinking water cubic metre is approximately a third smaller.
Digestion of wastewater sludge reduces emissions
By preventing evaporative emissions of wastewater in air, greenhouse gas emissions produced by water supply and sewerage could be most effectively mitigated. However, no experience exists of such solutions but controlling the gasses in underground facilities should be more successful than in facilities above ground.
In addition, emissions could be effectively reduced by utilising the organic matter in wastewater sludges better, and producing energy from it either through digestion or incineration. Harnessing the current digestion plant using flaring to the production of electricity and heat includes a notable mitigation potential.
Furthermore, emissions can be reduced by decreasing the energy consumption of pumps, mixers and other equipment and buildings with new technical solutions and by selecting low emission fuels for the production of electricity and heat. Emissions are also reduced when the sludges are used as a source of nutrients in urban landscaping or fields instead of filling the need with other products.
References ,
Checklist
Renewable energy: Is the energy content of wastewater sludge recovered in the area? Would it be possible to establish an anaerobic digestion plant or would the sludge be suitable for combustion by one of the energy production plants in the region?
Establishing an anaerobic digestion plant and producing energy from waste water sludge
Strengths, factors in favour |
Weaknesses, uncertainties |
Costs, economic impacts |
Electricity and/or heat can be produced from biogas, or it can be utilised in gas-powered vehicles. |
Suitable urban landscaping locations, or sufficient field area to deliver the nutrients to is not necessarily available at close range for the digestate produced by the plant. |
+ Employs Finnish design and planning offices and equipment suppliers. |
In addition to biogas, the plant produces digestate and concentrate with nutrients that can be returned to the ground. |
The markets and image of digestate can vary considerably in the market, influencing the sales of end products in different ways in different years. |
- Running costs increase if products from the plant have to be transported further away than planned. |
The anaerobic digestion plant can accept not only waste water sludge but other bio-based materials, too. |
The nutrient content of reject waters generated by the plant may prevent their delivery to a municipal wastewater treatment plant, which may result in the need to initiate own treatment activity. |
+ Employs local transport entrepreneurs and experts in natural sciences. |
Waste water sludge is generated evenly which makes plant operation continuous. |
Employees of plants utilising bio-based masses are exposed to odours and pollutants and microbes in the treated biomasses. |
+ More local employment opportunities (use of plant, transports) |
Thermophilic (at over 55 degrees C) digestion or the heating stage preceding digestion (temperature over 70 degrees C) also act as efficient hygienisers of sludge. |
Environmental nuisance caused by transports may increase in the vicinity of the plant. |
- Manure would be a co-digestion mass available in significant quantities but farmers do not necessarily have the financial incentives for delivering manure to the digestion plant: direct placement of manure in the fields is subject to environmental subsidy but spreading of digested manure is not. |
Biogas is a biogenic fuel classified as renewable fuel that can replace fossil fuels. |
Biogas must be purified before use as fuel in vehicles |
|
|
The activity may cause odour nuisance at close range. |
|
Renewable energy: Is biogas generated in digestion utilised in production of power and/or heat?
Incineration of waste water sludge
Strengths, factors in favour |
Weaknesses, uncertainties |
Costs, economic impacts |
Incineration eliminates any risks in terms of hygiene and infection related to waste water sludge. |
When waste water sludge is incinerated, the nitrogen and phosphorus nutrients contained in the sludge are lost in the air and ash. |
+/- Depending on the distances, incineration can be either a less or more expensive solution for taxpayers than digestion or other mechanical biological treatment. |
Since energy produced from waste water sludge is sourced from bio-based raw materials, it facilitates reaching of renewable energy production objectives. |
Extra waste heat is not necessarily available to facilitate sufficient preliminary drying of waste water sludge, which reduces the energy balance of treatment. |
-Reduces local employment opportunities (incineration plant operates with a low number of staff and less transports are required). |
Vast user experiences are available on incineration from other parts of the world where incineration of waste water sludge is the most common treatment method. |
Ash remains after incineration. Ways of utilising it must be found, or it must be placed in a landfill. |
|
When the end product is placed in one location, no transport traffic is needed to various directions. |
|
|
An increasing number of alternative combustion plants is available as new waste incineration plants are established in various parts of the country. |
|
|
Incineration and disposal of ash are straightforward, permanent solutions, independent of markets and trends. |
|
|
In certain conditions waste water sludge can possibly be utilised as fuel instead of other, e.g. fossil fuels. |
|
|
Waste management: Are composted and/or digested biomasses utilised in landscaping or in the fields?
Utilisation of end products from waste water sludge digestion in landscaping or in the fields
Strengths, factors in favour |
Weaknesses, uncertainties |
Costs, economic impacts |
Nitrogen and phosphorus nutrients return to the ecological cycle. |
Suitable urban landscaping locations, or sufficient field area to deliver the nutrients to is not necessarily available at close range for the digestate produced by the plant. |
+ For landscapers, soil produced from wastewater sludge may be a more economical solution than normal humus soil. |
Moisture and carbon returned to the ecological cycle. |
The markets and image of digestate can vary considerably in the market, influencing the sales of end products in different ways in different years. |
+ Productisation of digestate and reject water may prove considerable sources of employment in the region. |
The use of end products from treatment of waste water sludge in landscaping may reduce the amount of peat extracted as less peat soil can be produced. |
The nutrient content of reject waters generated by the plant may prevent their delivery to a municipal wastewater treatment plant. |
|
|
The aftertreatment of digestate may cause odour nuisance at close range. |
|
|
The residues of partly still unknown pharmaceuticals and fire retardants ending up in waste water sludge can be feared to constitute an environmental risk at least in certain cases. |
|